The Short Answer
A black and white cookie is a big, soft, cake-like round iced on its flat side with vanilla on one half and chocolate on the other. It is one of the most recognizable things in any New York bakery case, and it is a regular on the counter at Pier 69 Market, where you will find it listed on our menu alongside the rest of the sides and desserts.
It looks simple, and in a sense it is. But almost everything about it, from the texture to the icing to the order you eat it in, is a little different from what the word "cookie" leads you to expect. This guide covers what it is, where it comes from, how it compares to its upstate cousin, and how to enjoy one on a walk by the water.
It is called a cookie, it eats like a cake, and every New Yorker has an opinion about which side goes first.
What a Black and White Cookie Actually Is
Break one in half and the first surprise is the inside. A black and white is not crisp, chewy or crumbly the way a chocolate chip cookie is. The base is made from a loose, cake-style batter, closer to what you would use for a sponge or a muffin, scooped onto a sheet and baked into a wide, gently domed disc. That gives it a soft, springy crumb and a faint vanilla or lemon note, depending on the baker.
The second surprise is where the icing goes. The cookie is flipped and iced on the flat underside, which gives the icing a smooth, even surface to set on. One half gets white vanilla icing, the other half chocolate, with a straight line down the middle. The icing sets firm enough to stack and wrap, but stays soft enough to bite through cleanly.
Why it travels so well
That firm icing is also why the black and white has always been a grab-and-go item. It goes into a paper bag or a wax sleeve without smudging, survives a tote bag or a bike basket, and does not need a plate or a fork. Our guide to pastries in Bay Ridge calls it the most portable thing in the case, and that is still true.
Where It Comes From
Nobody can point to a single inventor. The black and white grew up in the bakeries of New York, many of them run by German and Central European immigrant bakers in the late 1800s and early 1900s, and it became a fixture in neighborhood bakeries, delis and diners across the five boroughs. Glaser's Bake Shop, a family bakery on the Upper East Side that opened in 1902 and closed in 2018, was one of the shops most closely associated with it.
A similar-looking cake cookie, the Amerikaner, is sold in Germany, which supports the idea that the style crossed the Atlantic with immigrant bakers. Whatever the exact path, by the twentieth century the black and white was simply part of what a New York bakery sold.
The Seinfeld effect
Plenty of people outside the city first heard of it from a 1994 episode of Seinfeld, "The Dinner Party," in which Jerry holds one up as a small lesson in getting along: the two halves sit side by side on the same cookie, and the best bite has both. It is a joke, but it is also a fair description of how the cookie tastes best, and it made the black and white a national symbol of New York food.
Black and White Cookie vs Half-Moon Cookie
Travel a few hours upstate and you will hear the same-looking treat called a half-moon. The Utica area is known for its own version, and the two are easy to mix up. The main difference is the topping.
- New York black and white: finished with a smooth, firm icing or fondant that sets to a glossy, almost glassy surface.
- Upstate half-moon: usually topped with a softer, thicker frosting that is closer to buttercream or fudge, piled on more generously.
Both are split into a chocolate half and a vanilla half, and both sit on a soft cake base. Ask a New Yorker and a Utica native which is better and you will get two confident, opposite answers.
How to Eat One
There are three schools of thought, and none of them is wrong.
- Vanilla first, chocolate last. The most common approach. Save the richer half for the end.
- Chocolate first. For people who know what they want and do not like waiting for it.
- Straight down the middle. Every bite gets a little of both. This is the Seinfeld method, and many bakers will quietly tell you it is how the cookie was designed to be eaten.
One practical tip: the icing is sweet, so a black and white is best eaten with something that pushes back against it. That brings us to the coffee.
What to Drink With a Black and White Cookie
The pairing that has lasted longest is the simplest one: a cup of plain black coffee. The bitterness and roast of a drip coffee cut right through the sugar in the icing, and the soft cake base soaks up a dunk without falling apart. At Pier 69 Market, that means a House Drip made with La Colombe coffee.
- House drip: the classic. Nothing to add.
- Americano: a little cleaner and sharper than drip. See our Americano vs drip coffee guide for the difference.
- A small milk drink: a cortado or flat white keeps the espresso forward without adding sweetness.
- Tea: a Rishi black tea has enough body to stand up to the icing.
What to skip: sweet, rich drinks such as a mocha or a hot chocolate. Two sweet things side by side tend to cancel each other out. Save those for a day when the drink is the treat.
A Black and White on the Bay Ridge Waterfront
Because it travels so well, the black and white is a natural companion for the neighborhood around Pier 69 Market. A few ways locals use it:
- The walk to the water. Pick up a cookie and a lidded coffee and head toward Owl's Head Park or the 69th Street Pier for a view of the Narrows.
- Before the ferry. A cookie in a bag is the easiest thing to carry onto the boat. Our NYC Ferry coffee guide covers the rest of the morning routine.
- The afternoon pick-me-up. We are open until 9 PM every day, so a coffee and a cookie works just as well at 3 PM as it does at 7 AM.
- Feeding a group. Cookies are easy to share at an office meeting, a school event or a party. Our birthday party food ideas and catering page are good starting points for larger orders.
Getting One at Pier 69 Market
Pier 69 Market is at 10 Bay Ridge Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, close to Owl's Head Park, the waterfront and the NYC Ferry. We are open Monday through Friday from 6 AM to 9 PM and on weekends from 7 AM to 9 PM. Black and white cookies are on the menu, but a bakery case is finite, so if you are making a special trip it is worth calling ahead at (718) 777-6969 to check what is in the case that day.
You can also order pickup or delivery through GetSauce. Cookies are one of the best things to have delivered: nothing to go cold, nothing to get soggy. For directions and parking, see our visit page.
Vanilla First or Chocolate First?
Black and white cookies, La Colombe coffee and Rishi tea at 10 Bay Ridge Ave. Open from 6 AM on weekdays and 7 AM on weekends. Call (718) 777-6969 for pickup.